Although the concept of a leader often conjures images of charismatic figures and larger-than-life personalities, leadership is never one-size-fits-all. Renowned and respected Canadian journalist Steve Paikin, whose career spans over 40 years, has interviewed thousands of leaders and figures from all over the world. One of his most interesting observations: There is no one type of successful leader.
As the keynote speaker for the 18th annual Thomas d’Aquino Lecture on Leadership, an annual event hosted by the Ian O. Ihnatowycz Institute for Leadership, Paikin shared observations gleaned from speaking with countless leaders over his career. He explored the contrasts between bold, magnetic leaders and those who lead with quiet strength and introspection.
Paikin – author, documentary producer, and the host of TVOntario’s flagship current affairs program, The Agenda with Steve Paikin – delivered his address at two separate events for the Thomas d’Aquino Lecture on Leadership. He spoke at an event for leaders from the public and private sectors on November 1 at the National Gallery of Canada in Ottawa and later gave a lecture for HBA1 students at Ivey on November 14.
The art of an understated leader
Paikin highlighted former Ontario Premier Bill Davis’s understated approach to leadership, which differed from the stereotypical "alpha" style. Despite being introverted and initially shy, Davis became a highly respected leader known for his quiet, deliberative style. Paikin noted Davis’s successful political career, marked by four election victories and decisions that shaped Ontario, including his support for Toronto’s downtown SkyDome, now the Rogers Centre.
Many people are too timid to lead, and yet, if and when they do, they will almost certainly find people who are happy to follow. We like leadership. We need it. We depend on it. And, despite our timidity, we can all do it.” – Steve Paikin
Lessons from a leader’s journey
Paikin went on to discuss former Prime Minister of Canada John Turner’s journey as a politician, from his early promise as a charismatic leader to his challenges later in life. Turner initially made significant contributions as Justice and then Finance Minister under Prime Minister Pierre Trudeau, enacting impactful reforms like decriminalizing homosexuality and easing divorce laws. However, after a decade in the private sector, Turner struggled to regain his leadership effectiveness upon returning to politics. Paikin acknowledged Turner’s eventual shift to championing democracy, inspiring younger generations to engage in public service and uphold democratic values.
Making the world better through modest, quiet acts
Strong examples of leadership aren’t just seen in politics. Sharing two thoughtful stories involving friends close to home, Paikin closed his keynote by emphasizing how leadership can emerge in simple, everyday actions.
He first described a hockey teammate who, by organizing a dinner for their group, created a bonding experience and displayed spontaneous leadership. Paikin then shared the story of a friend from Hamilton who organized a celebration for Eleanor Harvey, the first Canadian to win an Olympic fencing medal, showing that small, considerate acts of initiative can significantly impact a community.
We can’t all be the Premier; we can’t all be the Prime Minister; but we can all – through modest, quiet acts – be leaders and make our messed-up world a little better. So, let’s all do it.”
In 2006, Ivey established the annual Thomas d’Aquino Lecture on Leadership to salute Tom d’Aquino’s outstanding contributions to national and international business, public policy, and the volunteer sector. We are grateful to Mr. d'Aquino for his ongoing support of the Institute and this lecture.
